IT has taken the vigilance of the management of African Petroleum (AP) Plc to spot and blow the whistle on the finagling with the price of the company's shares on the Nigerian Stock Exchange. But by the time it raised the alarm through advertorials in the print media last month, the company's estimated 160,000 shareholders had lost about N240 billion in the value of their stocks. The manipulation of the share price occurred over an eight-week period this year through cross deals that were camouflaged as active trading but with the sinister motive of diluting the value of the stock. The AP share had been marked down at N273 from N300 during its public offer last year. The price was a bare N54 per share when the scam cross deals were exposed.
Amid the throes of the catastrophic losses of the Nigerian capital market in the past 13 months, the serious allegations of the manipulation of the share price of a well-heeled company like AP is bound to rattle tentative investors and put off altogether the already wearied losers in the impoverished market. Nevertheless, it is gratifying that the regulatory authorities, which were in a deep slumber while the share price manipulation lasted, have suddenly awoken to their responsibilities.
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has since announced a number of punitive measures. Nova Finance and Securities Limited, the firm that masterminded the illicit transactions, has been fined N190,000 and banned from operating in the capital market for one year. Similarly, the firm's managing director, Mr. Eugene Anenih, has been disqualified from being employed in any arm of the securities industry for the next five years.
On the other hand, Alhaji Aliko Dangote, the business mogul on whose behalf Nova Securities crossed the AP share deals, has been exonerated. This is because there was no evidence that Dangote gave explicit instructions to the stockbroking firm to trade in the manner it did. The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has also waded in on the strength of the petition filed by Mr. Femi Otedola, chairman/chief executive officer of AP. The EFCC is currently interrogating the dramatis personae, namely, Dangote, Anenih, and Otedola. Even though he also petitioned the House of Representatives Committee on the Capital Market and allied institutions, Otedola has twice shunned the Committee's summons, provoking threats of a parliamentary warrant of arrest. Both Dangote and Anenih and others have appeared before the Committee.
What is gradually emerging in the pubic domain are matters often discussed in hushed tones by some operators in the capital market who take the investing public for a ride. There is no question whatsoever that share price manipulation goes against the grain of market forces in determining the true value of a stock. Without the correct, or appropriate information, investors are often misled into taking decisions that may result in huge losses. This saps confidence and results in the diversion of resources and investible funds into other areas with the attendant consequences on the financial health of quoted companies. This is why the rules of the capital market frown at share price manipulation.
Sections 105 and 106, read together with section 115 of the Investment and Securities Act 2007 prohibit and criminalise false trading and market rigging transactions as well as securities market manipulation. For instance, s.105(1) provides that "A person shall not create, or cause to be created, or do anything which may create a false or misleading appearance: (a) of active trading in any securities on a securities exchange or capital trade point or (b) with respect to the market for the price of any such securities". Furthermore, s.105(2)(b) stipulates that "A person shall not by any fictitious transactions or devices maintain, inflate, depress, or cause fluctuations in the market price of any securities".
Obviously, the custodians of the rules, the Nigerian Stock Exchange and SEC, were either absent-minded or plain lethargic while Nova Securities over a period of eight weeks was fiddling with the share price of AP. This is one more instance of the glaring inadequacies of both the Exchange and SEC. Since March last year when the Nigerian capital market fell into a coma, accusing fingers have been pointed at the operators of the Exchange and its SEC monitors for their failure to detect and promptly deal with the range of factors that eventually precipitated the crash.
In this regard, we commend the government for facilitating the removal of the Director-General of SEC, Mallam Musa Al-Faki, who has been forced on compulsory leave, preparatory to his exit at the end of his five-year tenure in October, this year, without renewal of same. The Acting Director-General, Ms Daisy Ekineh, must see the new developments as a wake-up call for the commission to realise its mandate.
Meanwhile, the allegation of the manipulation of share prices is one issue that must never suffer the usual Nigerian fate of abandonment. The on-going investigations must get to the root of the matter. At the weekend, an advertorial sponsored by the 'Committee for the Defence of Justice and Advancement' drew attention to the meteoric rise in the value of AP shares between the first week in October 2007 and the second week in December 2007. This significant climb in share value occurred on the eve of the company reaching out to the market through public offer and rights issue.
Fresh allegations have also been made against Mr. Femi Otedola for allegedly manipulating the share price of Chevron Oil directly and through surrogates. These are all shocking developments indeed.
As hinted by Anenih while appearing before the House Committee, there may be other instances of manipulation perpetrated by other players in the market. What is required, therefore, is full disclosure of such price rigging. This means that the investigations must not be restricted to AP shares but should cover other companies for which allegations have also surfaced. This will, of course, be accompanied by sanctions in deserving cases. And to achieve the objective of full disclosure, the investigating committee and other agencies must strive to reach beyond persons who have been named in the current saga. Where necessary, let the agencies call for confidential petitions and memoranda, so that the net can be cast wide enough to fish out the outlaws in the Nigerian capital market.
Inherent in the AP matter is an object lesson for other companies quoted on the Exchange. It took the alertness of AP's management to detect and raise alarm over the fiddling with its share price. Other companies, in the interest of their teeming shareholders, must equally be on their watchposts, to apprehend the sort of illegality that has cost AP shareholders quite a fortune.
Source: Guardian News, Nigeria